I went on a date with a great guy last week. We both ordered salads and entrees at a famous restaurant in Los Angeles.
It was an exciting venue to meet someone for the first time, and I kept my eyes peeled for boldfaced names. Believe me when I say restaurant dates have been replaced by awkward walks in the park and coffee dates at Starbucks
in recent years, so it was nice to actually get dressed up and have something to look forward to.
But — yes, there’s a but — he ordered two glasses of wine, which cost $18 each. He had a Chardonnay with his salad, and a Cabernet with his main course. I don’t drink during the week and was happy to drink tap water, but I make no judgment about anyone who does choose to have a few drinks, especially on a first date.
His beverages added $36 to the bill, and I waited for him to say, “I’ll get the tip,” or “You don’t have to pay for my alcohol,” or even, “Would you like me to take the wine off and pay for it separately?” He did not do any of those things. Including tax and tip, that probably added over $20 to my bill. I paid my half of the bill.
Should I have spoken up? Is it OK to ask someone else to pay for your alcohol?
Dear First Dater,
I’ll break this down into two parts: Chardonnay Manners and Cabernet Dreams.
Let’s start with Chardonnay Manners: You did what you believed to be correct. You weighed up the $36, excluding tip and taxes, and figured it wasn’t worth making a fuss given that you liked this guy and had a nice time. But it leaves a hangover — ironic, given that you didn’t have any alcohol — and residual resentment over what you perceive to be his lack of consideration. Go on a second date, and if you see a pattern of penny-pinching, show him the door to the wine cellar.
Now onto Cabernet Dreams. What should he have done? If he were writing to this column, I would say, “Offer to pay for the beverages, and if she refuses, tip 20% and ensure that your date does not add a tip.” He did not do that. Yes, it’s a bit rich to expect someone to pay for your drinks. One glass of wine? I would let it slide. Two glasses of wine? I’d be on the fence, just like you. Three glasses of wine? I’d say, “I’m not paying for your wine, Buster!” And I’d say it with a smile.
As an aside, if your date invited you for dinner and chose the restaurant, it’s generally accepted that he should at least offer to pay. This survey conducted by the online-dating site Elite Singles surveyed 300,000 people. The conclusion: 63% of men said they should absolutely pay on a first date, while only 46% of the women agreed men should pay. In other words, it’s nice to offer, but you can always decline and insist on going Dutch (preferably without paying for his alcohol).
On a scale of 1 to 10 of bad dinner-date stories, yours was a 3. I’ve seen some 10s: There was the man whose friend sucker-punched him into paying for a $150 sushi feast because his friend had wrangled two free tickets to a concert, and he expected to be treated royally for the favor. Then there are the tales of people who spend their time arguing over which friend paid for what dish. You like this guy and still have time to set the ground rules. Next time, you will be prepared.
Be nice, be clear, and be assertive. They are all attractive qualities.
Related: Should the man always pick up the check?
Check out the Moneyist private Facebook group, where we look for answers to life’s thorniest money issues. Readers write in to me with all sorts of dilemmas. Post your questions, tell me what you want to know more about, or weigh in on the latest Moneyist columns.
The Moneyist regrets he cannot reply to questions individually.
By emailing your questions, you agree to having them published anonymously on MarketWatch. By submitting your story to Dow Jones & Company, the publisher of MarketWatch, you understand and agree that we may use your story, or versions of it, in all media and platforms, including via third parties.
‘I’m really upset’: I borrowed $10,000 from my brother with a $200-a-month payment plan. We fell out, and now he wants the money back in full
‘I am a 53-year-old single man with very little savings’: I want to take out a 30-year mortgage, but pay it off in 7 years. Is that possible?
I received a $130,000 inheritance from my mother. My husband says it’s mine to spend. What should I do with it — and why do I feel so guilty?